modernCSLewis

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, June 24, 2013

The Leftist corrosion of acknowledged existential dependence by the concept of Rights

Posted on 10:11 PM by Unknown
*

One of the terribly, existentially, damaging effects of Leftism has been to propagandize the falsehood that dependence - actual poverty, sickness, extremes of age, incapacity - brings with it the Right to be supported.

(These Rights being defined and enforced by the state who extract resources from one group of the population, keep some and distribute the rest to those with Rights.)

This large scale and all-but-universal policy of modern societies has inflicted many deep and deadly wounds on the souls of most modern citizens on both sides of the Rights divide - as was no doubt the demonic intention from the start - but one particularly anti-Christian wound has been to remove the spiritual benefits of poverty, sickness, childhood, old age or incapacity about which the scriptures are so clear.

*

The spiritual benefit arises from an acknowledgement of our own state of utter dependence.

We can still perceive this in young children. The great spiritual strength of children comes from their knowledge that they depend on their parents for everything, and from this comes trust - and this earthly knowledge of dependence is easily extended into a trust in God.

The spiritual beauty of acknowledged dependence in childhood is all-too-often replaced, and at an ever-earlier age, by that denial of dependence and assertion of Rights which is termed Youth: a state of extreme existential peril from which few seem fully to recover.

*

This business of acknowledged dependence is of extreme importance to the Christian life - indeed without a fundamental, bedrock acknowledgement of existential dependence it is hard to see how a Christian life is possible.

*

The secular Right have reacted against Leftist Rights-talk with a false and absurd assertion of Independence. This leads to an existential selfishness, a state of Pride in their supposed autonomy, a clinging to what they imagine they posses as of Right. Such Rightist Independence discourse is, then, merely a different form of Rights talk - merely an unChristian and economics-focused reaction against the pecking order of modern Leftism, while retaining the Prideful spiritual defects of Leftism.

*

Perhaps dependence is the main lesson we need to learn in our lives of incarnate mortality?

Such a recognition may then lead to choosing to love those (and they are many) upon whom we depend; and to love God.   

*

But the Leftist aims to replace this profound recognition of existential reality with an unassuageable resentment against those who do not provide us with what we feel we deserve and are due.

Thus the language of Rights - and these Rights have been extended from our Rights to resources, to a universal Right to high status (!), and since Political Correctness the Right to positive approval.

It is hard to imagine any state of mind better calculated to lead to damnation - that is, to a deliberately-chosen rejection of God - than the Leftist-inculcated rejection of acknowledged dependence and its replacement with a demand for our supposed Rights.

*
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Who had the highest IQ: JRR Tolkien or CS Lewis?
    * http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/tolkien-and-lewis-which-was-most.html *
  • Hobbit movie review
    * The Hobbit: an unexpected journey - 2012 Rating: three stars (from a possible five).^ * Although Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings m...
  • Observing the Sabbath
    * I was browsing through the Ten Commandments in the Catechism of the Book of Common Prayer, as one does, and noticed the phrase at the end ...
  • What does metaphysics mean in relation to Christianity?
    * Metaphysics is a very interesting subject - doubly so when it interacts with religion. Interesting - and misunderstood. * Metaphysics desc...
  • Favourite period of English history
    * I don't really have a favourite period of English history nowadays - tending to like specific bits and pieces from different eras and ...
  • What happens when we have had *enough* sleep?
    * In my experience, the same dream is recycled with only minor variations. I get stuck in a dream - a dream that repeats with minor variat...
  • Inklings in-jokes in the Notion Club Papers
    * http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/mapping-notion-club-onto-inklings.html *
  • Real understanding versus procedural pseudo-understanding: a collage of sentences
    * The typical modern educated person - by educated I mean someone with advanced educational certification - has zero understanding of comple...
  • William Boyce: a third rate, derivative composer - I like him!
    * William Boyce (1711-1779) was born 26 years after GF Handel, but wrote exactly as if he was Handel; I, at any rate, cannot distinguish the...
  • Omnipotence bleg - and the problem of pain
    * Reading McMurrin's comparative historical analysis of Christian theology (see reference below) was fascinating in many ways - one of w...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (424)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (57)
    • ►  July (71)
    • ▼  June (60)
      • What happens when we have had *enough* sleep?
      • The Kingdom of God is brought about by mutual Love...
      • Losing Christian faith *entails* abandoning Christ...
      • The absurd prominence of the Holy Trinity in evang...
      • Why so much debate concerning the term 'Reactionar...
      • Van Wyck Brooks - The Flowering of New England (1936)
      • Why did 1960s critics, teachers and librarians fai...
      • Father Seraphim Rose: the beginning of an era - or...
      • Inclusiveness (Relativism, Tolerance, Multicultura...
      • Sleep satiety - when you have had *enough* sleep
      • Review of Against Inclusiveness by James Kalb
      • The macho posturing of pseudonymous (or anonymous)...
      • Bandy legs versus knock knees
      • Retrospective prayer, the impossibility of. Changi...
      • The most popular posts ever on this blog
      • Bruce Charlton Sacked - Impact Factor trends and t...
      • He "wants" to put the clock back
      • The Leftist corrosion of acknowledged existential ...
      • Implicit and explicit meanings in the Bible
      • Psychoticism as the primary personality trait
      • How to choose a denomination?
      • Assuming bad intentions
      • I require of theology...
      • The dementing society
      • A crude classification of societies by average int...
      • What are currently called 'examinations' would hav...
      • MA Woodley's Treadmill metaphor to explain why the...
      • Haiku: *Everything* lost in translation
      • Double-negative morality - the triumph of secularism
      • A positive marriage/child ratio - index of ruling ...
      • Escaping alienation into Art, or maybe Mythology?
      • But seriously, what are the prospects for Catholic...
      • Pluralism is true, God is within reality: a metaph...
      • Graphic sexual slang on secular Right blogs - what...
      • In this refulgent summer...
      • The sophomoric Red Pill nonsense
      • Free will is not exactly God-given but, ultimately...
      • A breakthrough in understanding creativity - the p...
      • What is the use of mathematics in biology?
      • 2008 - We were warned but it did no good. We did n...
      • Dignity in Dying - Your choice: prolonged torture ...
      • Socially-conditioned ingratitude - Leftist family ...
      • Max, Nigel Molesworth, Just William, Horrid Henry ...
      • Everybody wants 'a happy life' - differences are a...
      • On re-reading Ralph Waldo Emerson - two comments, ...
      • One cannot be pro- or anti- "war"
      • The Fall of Arthur by JRR Tolkien - Review
      • The coming Great Simplification
      • This blog versus "Tolkien's Notion Club Papers"
      • The savage triviality of modern media morality
      • Why is Sexy/Hot a term of approbation?
      • The spirituality of non-discrimination
      • Where do Leftist ideas come from?
      • Why are The Inklings now so popular? Four suggestions
      • All that comes from God is pure, clear, easy to un...
      • The nature of the mass media - a demonic impersona...
      • A problem with Protestants (specifically) and women
      • Christianity as a mystery religion
      • Religion in Numenor
      • Grasping at straws supposedly indicative of a chan...
    • ►  May (49)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (39)
    • ►  January (45)
  • ►  2012 (76)
    • ►  December (52)
    • ►  November (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile