modernCSLewis

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Saturday, June 8, 2013

Everybody wants 'a happy life' - differences are about the perceived nature of 'life'

Posted on 10:30 PM by Unknown
*

When someone asks the purpose of life, the answer can become a bit convoluted - but the simple and universal answer is to be happy.

On this, I think, everyone agrees - everyone seeks a happy life.

The differences come when considering the scope of 'life'.

*

The three main variables are:

1. Time-scale - short-term versus long-term

There are trade-offs between being happy immediately and being as happy as possible overall, across life; between the immediate certainty of here-and-now happiness by doing exactly what you want, and deferring happiness now - or accepting suffering - as an investment in building less-certain but potentially greater happiness later.


2. Mortal life versus post-mortal life

The modern secular person is concerned only by happiness during mortal life, but most religious people are concerned with happiness across a life which extends beyond mortality. Therefore the scope of a happy life varies in duration between a finite (but uncertain) number of hours, days or decades; up to some greater unit than mortality, which varies between religions and extends up to infinity.


3. Personal happiness versus the happiness of a larger unit

There is a wide variation in the understanding of that unit whose happiness is to be pursued and maximized. At one extreme it is just me - the individual; but beyond that there are many increasingly larger units of all believers; the family, tribe, nation; all humans, the living world - potentially up to the whole existing universe.

*

If it is assumed that the desire for a happiness is intrinsic and universal, this scheme can be used to classify all religions (whether private or public) in terms of whether the aimed-at happiness is now or later, for mortal life or beyond, and just for me or some larger group.

Both the modern secular hedonist and the devout Christian seek a happy, but the differences in attitudes and behaviour may be vast - not because they conceptualize happiness differently, but because they perceive reality differently; and therefore conceptualize the scope of happiness and the scope of life differently.

If you see 'life' as ending in death, and only concerning your-self, then a strategy of maximizing happiness leads to quite different results from a person who sees 'life' as extending beyond death and encompassing others people - past, present and/or future.

*

All people are the same insofar as they all want to be happy, their aim is to have a happy life; and differences between people can be reduced to differences in the perceived nature of reality. 

*


[Note: Differences between people 'can be' reduced to differences in perceived nature of reality - and this is enlightening in some ways; but this analysis (this kind of analysis) is necessarily a reduction. Meaning that much is left-out by it. To put it mildly.]
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Attitudes and the Thought Police: opponents of Leftism cannot be subversive
    * New Leftism, post-mid-sixties Leftism, has been about shaping 'attitudes' - and this leads directly to the Thought Police For Left...
  • Who had the highest IQ: JRR Tolkien or CS Lewis?
    * http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/tolkien-and-lewis-which-was-most.html *
  • Free will entails a plurality of gods
    * By which I mean that free will makes each Man into something very much like the God of the philosophers: an unmoved mover, an uncaused cau...
  • How to make a Patagonian Shakespeare
    ...is the name of a new blog I am intending to work on - with a view to writing a book of that name. http://patagonianshakespeare.blogspot.c...
  • The bass part of music
    * The bass part seems to be liked - even though it is seldom noticed (some unmusical people seem unable to hear it). When the bass comes in,...
  • The Left isn't winning by having good arguments - it wins because people are punished for arguing against the Left
    * This is one of the things I find most frustrating, and increasingly frustrating: not so much that it happens, but that so many people cann...
  • Free will, the torturer and the tortured
    * If free will is real - as it is - then the extreme torturer (and nobody and nothing else) really is responsible for his choice to inflict ...
  • What do 'antipsychotics' do to people?
    * An interesting quote from Robert Whitaker's Anatomy of an Epidemic: magic bullets, psychiatric drugs, and the astonishing rise of ment...
  • Free will implies/ entails pre-mortal existence
    * I find the following line of argument very convincing. Edited, and with bold emphases added, from pages 47-51 of  The God who weeps by Te...
  • Why remain a Church of England Anglican?
    * Given all my nasty (and well-deserved) criticisms of the Church of England, why am I a member? 1. I was baptized into into it, I attended ...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (424)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (57)
    • ►  July (71)
    • ▼  June (60)
      • What happens when we have had *enough* sleep?
      • The Kingdom of God is brought about by mutual Love...
      • Losing Christian faith *entails* abandoning Christ...
      • The absurd prominence of the Holy Trinity in evang...
      • Why so much debate concerning the term 'Reactionar...
      • Van Wyck Brooks - The Flowering of New England (1936)
      • Why did 1960s critics, teachers and librarians fai...
      • Father Seraphim Rose: the beginning of an era - or...
      • Inclusiveness (Relativism, Tolerance, Multicultura...
      • Sleep satiety - when you have had *enough* sleep
      • Review of Against Inclusiveness by James Kalb
      • The macho posturing of pseudonymous (or anonymous)...
      • Bandy legs versus knock knees
      • Retrospective prayer, the impossibility of. Changi...
      • The most popular posts ever on this blog
      • Bruce Charlton Sacked - Impact Factor trends and t...
      • He "wants" to put the clock back
      • The Leftist corrosion of acknowledged existential ...
      • Implicit and explicit meanings in the Bible
      • Psychoticism as the primary personality trait
      • How to choose a denomination?
      • Assuming bad intentions
      • I require of theology...
      • The dementing society
      • A crude classification of societies by average int...
      • What are currently called 'examinations' would hav...
      • MA Woodley's Treadmill metaphor to explain why the...
      • Haiku: *Everything* lost in translation
      • Double-negative morality - the triumph of secularism
      • A positive marriage/child ratio - index of ruling ...
      • Escaping alienation into Art, or maybe Mythology?
      • But seriously, what are the prospects for Catholic...
      • Pluralism is true, God is within reality: a metaph...
      • Graphic sexual slang on secular Right blogs - what...
      • In this refulgent summer...
      • The sophomoric Red Pill nonsense
      • Free will is not exactly God-given but, ultimately...
      • A breakthrough in understanding creativity - the p...
      • What is the use of mathematics in biology?
      • 2008 - We were warned but it did no good. We did n...
      • Dignity in Dying - Your choice: prolonged torture ...
      • Socially-conditioned ingratitude - Leftist family ...
      • Max, Nigel Molesworth, Just William, Horrid Henry ...
      • Everybody wants 'a happy life' - differences are a...
      • On re-reading Ralph Waldo Emerson - two comments, ...
      • One cannot be pro- or anti- "war"
      • The Fall of Arthur by JRR Tolkien - Review
      • The coming Great Simplification
      • This blog versus "Tolkien's Notion Club Papers"
      • The savage triviality of modern media morality
      • Why is Sexy/Hot a term of approbation?
      • The spirituality of non-discrimination
      • Where do Leftist ideas come from?
      • Why are The Inklings now so popular? Four suggestions
      • All that comes from God is pure, clear, easy to un...
      • The nature of the mass media - a demonic impersona...
      • A problem with Protestants (specifically) and women
      • Christianity as a mystery religion
      • Religion in Numenor
      • Grasping at straws supposedly indicative of a chan...
    • ►  May (49)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (39)
    • ►  January (45)
  • ►  2012 (76)
    • ►  December (52)
    • ►  November (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile