modernCSLewis

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Can you handle it?

Posted on 11:31 PM by Unknown
*

A lot of modern life is about rubbing people's noses in stuff that they find disgusting, repellent, sickening - this sometimes seem like the main activity and underlying purpose of the mass media, backed by the highbrow artistic establishment.

The idea is, of course, to desensitize us so that nothing can shock us because then we will accept evil.

A secondary purpose is to de-sacralize that which is sacred, so it will cease to command our loyalty.

*

As a doctor I have been through a very thorough training in desensitization with respect to disease - I had to overcome my revulsion for dead bodies, gross skin rashes, and overpowering smells in order that I could work with patients.

Part of this was a kind of pre-preparation to control one's facial expression and vocal tone so as to prevent any observable disgust, I was learning an imperturbable manner. It was necessary.

But that extracted a price in terms of hardening of my personality, especially when combined with the gruelling long hours, and even more especially in psychiatry - where the hardening was applied to psychological (rather than physical) factors that seemed to spill over into other relationships.

I began to dislike the person I had become - and that was a major reason why I stopped doing clinical work.

(This was a defect in me personally - not all doctors suffer this excessive hardening, and good clinicians develop the necessary imperturbability while retaining empathy. But the difficulty of this combination is one reason - among several - why most people cannot practice medicine, why the profession must be selective.)

*

Our culture is far down this path of psychological hardening, callousness. 

The good excuse for it is that many people, through no fault of their own, are disgusting; and by reacting to to them with disgust we increase their suffering.

This could be a defensible therapeutic attitude to society; but modern society is not defensible - because instead of imperturbability we practice an inversion by which that which spontaneously evokes negative feelings such as disgust is valorized - regarded as better than that which is spontaneously regarded as desirable.

Spontaneous disgust is not controlled but inverted: we are trained that disgust should be followed by, suppressed by, overwhelmed by positive regard.

*

It is as if medical students were trained to regard sickening smells as fragrant, gross skin rashes as beautiful and dead bodies as in a better condition than live ones.

That is the difference between desensitization and inversion - desensitization may be necessary and may even be desirable, although there is a significant price to pay; but inversion is insane.

*

Now mainstream culture rubs our noses in the disgusting stuff of life, of which there is an endless supply, and we are not supposed to notice that it is disgusting, instead we are supposed to find it admirable and praiseworthy.

Mainstream modern culture does not merely 'tolerate' the disgusting, it strategically seeks-out the disgusting, in order to celebrate and reward it; behaving like an anti-therapeutic- 'doctor' who poisons his patients and spreads diseases on the rationale that sickness and death are preferable to health and life.

*
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Attitudes and the Thought Police: opponents of Leftism cannot be subversive
    * New Leftism, post-mid-sixties Leftism, has been about shaping 'attitudes' - and this leads directly to the Thought Police For Left...
  • Who had the highest IQ: JRR Tolkien or CS Lewis?
    * http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/tolkien-and-lewis-which-was-most.html *
  • Free will entails a plurality of gods
    * By which I mean that free will makes each Man into something very much like the God of the philosophers: an unmoved mover, an uncaused cau...
  • How to make a Patagonian Shakespeare
    ...is the name of a new blog I am intending to work on - with a view to writing a book of that name. http://patagonianshakespeare.blogspot.c...
  • The bass part of music
    * The bass part seems to be liked - even though it is seldom noticed (some unmusical people seem unable to hear it). When the bass comes in,...
  • The Left isn't winning by having good arguments - it wins because people are punished for arguing against the Left
    * This is one of the things I find most frustrating, and increasingly frustrating: not so much that it happens, but that so many people cann...
  • Free will, the torturer and the tortured
    * If free will is real - as it is - then the extreme torturer (and nobody and nothing else) really is responsible for his choice to inflict ...
  • What do 'antipsychotics' do to people?
    * An interesting quote from Robert Whitaker's Anatomy of an Epidemic: magic bullets, psychiatric drugs, and the astonishing rise of ment...
  • Free will implies/ entails pre-mortal existence
    * I find the following line of argument very convincing. Edited, and with bold emphases added, from pages 47-51 of  The God who weeps by Te...
  • Why remain a Church of England Anglican?
    * Given all my nasty (and well-deserved) criticisms of the Church of England, why am I a member? 1. I was baptized into into it, I attended ...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (424)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (57)
    • ►  July (71)
    • ►  June (60)
    • ►  May (49)
    • ►  April (30)
    • ▼  March (51)
      • Argument with Leftists is like telling Nazis that ...
      • Is it that God will not make us enter Heaven, or c...
      • Favourite period of English history
      • Free will entails a plurality of gods
      • Snow, snail, snil, snoil, hail
      • Can you handle it?
      • Marshall McLuhan's (one) Big Idea
      • The perils of prolonged dating (and cohabitation)
      • Pragmatism and religion
      • Wildly inaccurate fantasy cover art
      • If you are not religious, you are a sex-addict
      • The ideal truth about family life
      • The remarkable thing that is free will
      • Welby-watch - enthronement speech. What is an 'eva...
      • Have the ranks of the high-IQ Outsiders been swell...
      • My innate pragmatism and pluralism twangs-back...
      • Potter versus Rowling
      • Mere Christianity - losing faith in the power of t...
      • The Christian Evolutionist
      • The comment that threw into doubt my previous idea...
      • What is the purpose of the discourse of the biolog...
      • God's power
      • Free will, the torturer and the tortured
      • Charles Williams on the implications of God's omni...
      • Natural selection: its power and its limitations
      • Inklings in-jokes in the Notion Club Papers
      • What does natural selection operate upon?
      • Where lies hope? A Schumpeterian analysis
      • Shippey on bureaucracy
      • Shamans!
      • Christianity ought to be the warmest and most pers...
      • Absolute abstractions can make people crazy
      • The harshness of selection for higher intelligence...
      • Why does God do things in such roundabout and indi...
      • The mass media versus religion: a neo-McLuhanite a...
      • The climate has cooled - for sure...
      • Attitude to the sexual revolution is the single mo...
      • Mega randomized clinical trials and their intrinsi...
      • Implications of the reality of Man's free agency
      • When words fail
      • The Good News, and the bad news
      • Is THIS BLOG part of the mass media?
      • Real understanding versus procedural pseudo-unders...
      • Asking the right questions about the mass media: p...
      • Defending a clear, strong and simple understanding...
      • Why is the mass media intrinsically anti-Good? Bec...
      • Why did mobile phones and social networking turn o...
      • More on Tolkien's niggler-status
      • The analgesic properties of tubular elastic bandages
      • Explaining eternal goodness - a speculative story/...
      • Theosis and free agency
    • ►  February (39)
    • ►  January (45)
  • ►  2012 (76)
    • ►  December (52)
    • ►  November (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile