modernCSLewis

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, May 13, 2013

The Holy Trinity explained! - by Orson Scott Card

Posted on 9:02 AM by Unknown
*

From:

http://www.deseretnews.com/article/695233910/Theology-LDS-god-is-in-harmony-with-the-Bible.html?pg=all

Here's a theological argument between a traditional Christian (TC) and a biblical Christian (LDS):

TC: The Trinity consists of three parallel lines, which touch each other. 

LDS: If they touch each other, they're not parallel. 

TC: Nevertheless, they are parallel, and they touch. They touch at every point. 

LDS: If they touch at every point, they're the same line. Not three.

TC: They touch at every point, yet there are three.

LDS: That doesn't make any sense. Lines can't be different yet the same, parallel yet intersecting. The words stop having any meaning when you say such things.

TC: That's because you have a finite, mortal mind, which cannot comprehend the nature of geometry.

LDS: That's just crazy. The Trinity is three lines, completely distinct, perfectly parallel, so they go infinitely in the same direction. That's simple, it's clear, and it's true. In fact, we've seen the lines.

TC: That's blasphemy! You can never see the lines! They're only imaginary!

LDS: Your lines are imaginary. The lines we've seen are real.

TC: Then you are not Geometers!

And that's where the discussion always ends.

*

I side with the LDS-ite in this debate - because, even if I might disagree with this sufficiency and precision of this formulation of the Trinity, I can at least understand what it is I am disagreeing-with! To agree or disagree with the TC definition of the nature of the Trinity is to assent to, or dissent from, the content of a sealed black box which might contain anything or nothing, or both everything and nothing... 

*   
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Who had the highest IQ: JRR Tolkien or CS Lewis?
    * http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/tolkien-and-lewis-which-was-most.html *
  • Hobbit movie review
    * The Hobbit: an unexpected journey - 2012 Rating: three stars (from a possible five).^ * Although Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings m...
  • Observing the Sabbath
    * I was browsing through the Ten Commandments in the Catechism of the Book of Common Prayer, as one does, and noticed the phrase at the end ...
  • What does metaphysics mean in relation to Christianity?
    * Metaphysics is a very interesting subject - doubly so when it interacts with religion. Interesting - and misunderstood. * Metaphysics desc...
  • Favourite period of English history
    * I don't really have a favourite period of English history nowadays - tending to like specific bits and pieces from different eras and ...
  • What happens when we have had *enough* sleep?
    * In my experience, the same dream is recycled with only minor variations. I get stuck in a dream - a dream that repeats with minor variat...
  • Inklings in-jokes in the Notion Club Papers
    * http://notionclubpapers.blogspot.co.uk/2013/03/mapping-notion-club-onto-inklings.html *
  • Real understanding versus procedural pseudo-understanding: a collage of sentences
    * The typical modern educated person - by educated I mean someone with advanced educational certification - has zero understanding of comple...
  • William Boyce: a third rate, derivative composer - I like him!
    * William Boyce (1711-1779) was born 26 years after GF Handel, but wrote exactly as if he was Handel; I, at any rate, cannot distinguish the...
  • Omnipotence bleg - and the problem of pain
    * Reading McMurrin's comparative historical analysis of Christian theology (see reference below) was fascinating in many ways - one of w...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (424)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (57)
    • ►  July (71)
    • ►  June (60)
    • ▼  May (49)
      • Which infinities are easiest to believe?
      • Christian leadership and the willingness to employ...
      • Sleep in Heaven?
      • What happens to Short-term/ Working memory during ...
      • Dark Enlightenment: a perfectly descriptive phrase...
      • What seems static is actually cyclical
      • Reaction times in a 'perfectly matched' Victorian ...
      • The spineless state of the nation
      • Dreams are grown-from memories
      • The importance of non-writers to a writers group.....
      • "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary eviden...
      • Was CS Lewis a misogynist?
      • Alister McGrath's new biography of CS Lewis reviewed
      • Should men OR women dominate the church? (Since ne...
      • The secular Right's recurrent choice between being...
      • Was Charles Williams the key Inkling? An hypothesi...
      • Trance, dream, prophecy and revelation
      • Two kinds of nodding-off: absence or micro-dream ...
      • Is drowsy prayer acceptable - even good?
      • The (biological) function/s of sleep
      • Free will and sleep (and psychosis, dementia, damage)
      • The structure of life: waking and (two types of) s...
      • Who is against psychoactive drugs?
      • Two ways of being a Tolkien fan
      • What would it take for the Left to accept heredita...
      • Understanding Leftist IQ heresy hunts
      • Roman domestication of humans?
      • Some more stuff about the decline in intelligence ...
      • Are dragons really real?
      • Who was the holiest man who ever lived?
      • The Holy Trinity explained! - by Orson Scott Card
      • The metaphysical 'law' of Comparative Advantage - ...
      • The necessity of understanding God anthropomorphic...
      • Why construct Christian utopias?
      • Intelligence declined one SD since Victorian times...
      • A three point plan to solve everything
      • I'm blogging at Mad in America
      • Approximately one standard deviation decline of in...
      • Why is the secular Right blogosphere seething with...
      • A satisfying and coherent theory of Christ's atone...
      • Sin is Self-Absorbed Alienation
      • Tolkien envy bleg
      • Rowan Williams and Catweazle - separated at birth?
      • Choosing a church - advice from an in-expert
      • Is it possible to do good things for bad reasons? ...
      • Nothing to work with... The problem of motivation
      • Gratitude - the difference between Christian and a...
      • Modern life - since the sexual revolution = dating...
      • If Leftism does not come from Christianity - where...
    • ►  April (30)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (39)
    • ►  January (45)
  • ►  2012 (76)
    • ►  December (52)
    • ►  November (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile